[sticky entry] Sticky: (no subject)

Apr. 20th, 2017 08:29 pm
[personal profile] foxy_dw
Welcome to the Men of Middle-earth Awards, where we celebrated the beautiful variety of the LOTR slash fandom. The awards recognized some of the best of each pairing in RPS and FPS for drabbles, ficlets, and short and long fiction.

The MoMEs were held from 2007 through 2010, presenting 280 awards from hundreds of nominations of fics (both new and old) representing a broad spectrum of pairings from all corners of the fandom. This was truly a labor of love, one that proved to me that the Rings fandom will always be one of the best around.

The awards would not have been possible without the enthusiastic support of so many people. To anyone who ever participated in any form - whether through promoting, nominating, reading, commenting, voting, you name it - you have my sincere thanks. And a special mention to [personal profile] galor5 (2007) and [personal profile] stormatdusk (2008-2010) for creating such beautiful graphics.

There are many broken links in the posts as over time journals have been deleted or stories moved. If a fic link doesn't work, try looking for the author on Dreamwidth or AO3; you can also search for the story (by title and character) on AO3 and, of course, google might be able to locate some fics as well.
[identity profile] foxrafer.livejournal.com
This is mostly a placeholder post to keep the community from being deleted for inactivity, but it's also an announcement that I'm going to make a back-up of it on Dreamwidth to make sure the posts are archived somewhere.

I don't use Dreamwidth (I'll be setting up a temporary journal so I can save a copy of the community, but my actual journal is staying here on LJ) so if anyone who *is* moving wants to take over the comm on that site, just let me know and I'll figure out how to switch ownership/moderation/whatever it's called :).
[identity profile] foxrafer.livejournal.com
Hello, everyone. Once again I find myself having to apologize to all of you. I've made promises I couldn't keep and made commitments I haven't been able to live up to. I am truly sorry for this year's awards not getting off the ground, all of which is entirely my fault.

Any other year I'd probably say that we could begin again; create a new timeline and still get the awards done for 2012. However, my life right now doesn't afford me any mental capacity to handle much of anything beyond the basics of breathing, eating and sleeping. It's not even that the work itself is unreasonable; it's that I don't have the energy, confidence or passion to see it through.

Back in April, before things got too bad, someone kindly volunteered to help me pull everything together. I seriously considered the offer because I could feel things were sliding, but even then to just think about e-mailing all the files and forwarding all the nominations was too much. I know that sounds ridiculous (it is pretty ridiculous) but it was, and is, still true. Therefore, I'm afraid I'm going to have to say that the awards will not happen this year, and unless something seriously changes over the next few months, they will not happen again.

First, I would like to thank everyone who sent in nominations or promoted the awards this year. And to anyone who ever participated in any form over the past few years - whether through nominating, reading, commenting, voting, you name it - all of my sincerest gratitude. This has truly been such a wonderful fandom project to take on, and it is something I've absolutely enjoyed. It's been an honor to meet all of you, and you've solidified my belief that this fandom is filled with the kindest, most inviting and fun people I've ever had the privilege to know. I'm sorry this is going out on such a whimper, but I hope the past few months haven't irreparably altered how you'll remember the MOMEs. It will always be something in which I hold fond memories.

What I am going to do over the next few weeks is put together a list of all the stories and authors who were nominated this year and post it here as a way to celebrate them and their work, to give them some of the recognition they deserve. The kind person who volunteered to lend a hand earlier this year has agreed to help get that together, so keep an eye out for it around the end of the month.

Once again, I'm sorry for not getting this off the ground this year and for bringing it to a close. It's been great fun and I hope you've enjoyed yourself as well. Thank you for all of the kindness and generosity you've shown me over the years. I truly appreciate it and all of you.
[identity profile] foxrafer.livejournal.com
Hello, everyone. I am so sorry for falling behind and the delay in processing everything. And I'm afraid I won't be able to even start pulling the complete nomination list together until the weekend, after which things should begin to proceed at a good pace.

What this means is if anyone had any last minute stories they wanted to nominate, I'm happy to accept them through the end of the day on Friday, May 18.

Our revised schedule: voting will begin on June 4 and run through July 14. The winners will be announced by July 21.

My apologies once more for the delay. I think we've received a really nice number of nominations so far, and I'm looking forward to pulling everything together and getting e-mails sent out over the weekend. Thank you so much for your patience and your continued participation.
[identity profile] foxrafer.livejournal.com
To give everyone enough time to find their favorite fics and get their nominations in, the deadline for submitting nominations has been extended until the end of the month. Everyone now has four more weeks to go through their memories and bookmarks and find those stories you can't get enough of.

Voting will now begin on May 15, but the rest of the schedule should remain the same. If you have any questions, just let me know.
[identity profile] foxrafer.livejournal.com


Nominations are now being accepted for the Men of Middle-earth Awards!

A pairing will only become its own category if it receives at least three distinct nominations in a specific fic size written by at least two different authors. If awards are going to be presented to as wide a variety of pairings as possible, it's important that we receive a lot of nominations.

Nomination Tip: If you know of at least three ficlets (or drabbles, short fiction, etc.) in your favorite pairing that you consider to be exceptional and worthy of recognition, consider nominating all three and not just the one you like the most. That way you can almost guarantee that pairing will have its own category in that particular fic size.

You don't have to be a member to submit a story. So spread the word, find those exemplary stories and nominate, nominate, nominate!

Details inside )
[identity profile] foxrafer.livejournal.com
I know it seemed like this was never going to happen, but in a weeks time we will begin to accept nominations for this years MOME awards. I want to thank everyone for your encouragement and support over the past few years, and your willingness to shift the schedule. Because of the change, this year stories are eligible that have been written during an 18-month-period: July 1, 2010 through December 31, 2011. (In the future eligibility will be the previous calendar year, so next year stories written anytime in 2012 will be eligible.) Classic fics must have been completed by December 31, 2009.

Nominations will be accepted between February 12 and April 7, so start sifting through your bookmarks, memories, and favorite comms and get your list of fics together. There will be a post available for pointing readers to your fic or recommendation lists; it should be up in about a couple of weeks.

I received a suggestion last year about acknowledging nominees earlier in the process, which is a very good idea. I am going to attempt to contact everyone within a week of a story being nominated to alert them to the recognition before the ballots have been finalized. I will also continue to post a full nomination list at the end of the awards.

Another change we're implementing this year is to eliminate categories where all the stories on the ballot were written by the same author. (An exception would be if one story was co-written.) In order for a pairing to have its own category in any of the four fic-size divisions, it must have at least three stories nominated written by at least two different authors. So, for example, if there are three Dom/Elijah ficlets eligible but they were all written by RingsWriter1 there wouldn't be a separate Dom/Elijah ficlet category. However, if one of the ficlets were written by another author (or by RingsWriter1 and a co-author), there could be a Dom/Elijah ficlet category on the ballot.

More detailed information about the awards, including a full schedule, is currently posted on the profile page. If you have any questions about the categories, the process, eligibility, etc., please leave a comment here or send me an e-mail.

One thing I know is while our fandom may be smaller we are definitely still going strong. I'm looking forward to this year and sharing my love of all things Lord of the Rings with all of you.
[identity profile] foxrafer.livejournal.com

Only the stories that received the most nominations were on the final ballot. However, all of the stories that were submitted are worthy of recognition. Here you'll find a list of all the stories that were nominated organized by pairing (some fics may be f-locked). Use it as a reading list, an archive, or a place to refill your fandom tank when someone once again proclaims that the LotR fandom is dead. :-)

My apologies for taking so long to post this. A lot of it was done by hand because my merge file wasn't working the way I was expecting it to, so if there are any errors (incorrect link, a missed story or misspelled name) please let me know and I'll correct the error ASAP.

And if you haven't already, please leave a comment here with your feedback on the awards and with any suggestions for changes to the process. I haven't responded to the ones left so far because I want to leave the floor open to everyone else before I say anything, but I have read them and have been thinking of how to incorporate them into the rules.

Thanks again to everyone who participated. I'd love if every possible pair could be represented on the ballot next year, so if anyone has suggestions of comms or other places I can promote the awards, please let me know. Also, if you'd like to be a MOME cheerleader for your OTP, give me a shout. *g*

2010 FPS Nominations )

2010 RPS Nominations )
[identity profile] foxrafer.livejournal.com
Hello, everyone! I hope you're all doing well, enjoying the season (whether it's hot or cold where you are) and our wonderful fandom.

First an apology. I'm sorry that I haven't posted the list of all nominated stories yet. No excuses other than my own scattered brain. I wanted to get it done before writing this message, and the only thing that served was delaying this post for a month. I am going to finish it and it will be posted before the end of the month.

The main thing I wanted to talk about is the schedule for the next awards season. When I started the MOMEs, I chose to begin in the middle of the year because the [livejournal.com profile] slashy_oscars started in January. It made sense not to split people's attention between them. But it's become painfully obvious that the end of the year is a difficult time for me. I inevitably let things slide, which hasn't proved to be a death knell for the MOMEs thanks to all of you, but things could have been better had I been giving them the right attention. Plus at the end of the year there are a lot of fic exchanges and festivals, NaNoWriMo is right in the middle of it, holidays and vacations are prevalent. It feels like there are a lot of things vying for everyone's attention and perhaps it would be easier for everyone if we shifted the timetable so everything begins in January (possibly with nominations starting in December just to give a little extra time).

What would this mean for this year? Technically there wouldn't be any awards given out in 2011. Nominations would likely be open beginning late in December and running through January or mid-February, voting would be another 4 - 6 weeks (so ending around the end of March) with awards given out in April. Eligibility dates would shift accordingly.

What do you think?

[Poll #1757853]

In addition, I'd like to hear your feedback and/or suggestions about the awards in general. What do you think works, what do you think is totally borked, what might you tweak to get better results, places you would try and promote. Anything and everything you have to say, I'd love to hear it. If things move to a January timetable, there's plenty of time to revamp processes and get some templates in place so we can start fresh in 2012. You can always be forthright and straightforward with me, but to help facilitate things I've turned off IP logging and allowed anonymous comments.

Thanks for always being so supportive and for keeping this thing going even when I didn't have the energy to keep it afloat myself. The MOMEs would be nothing without you, and I'm incredibly appreciative of everyone.
[identity profile] foxrafer.livejournal.com

As always, this year wouldn't have been possible without all of you. Your help promoting the awards, your nominations, your stories and your votes: all of it means we're ending on a huge high. I want to give big thanks to everyone!

There were a few fics that were clear favorites, but the vast majority of the categories were as tight as always. Our fandom may be smaller but we're far from dead. :-)

Congratulations to all the winners, everyone on the final ballot and all the nominations! And thanks to [livejournal.com profile] stormatdusk for her gorgeous graphics!

2010 MOME Awards Results! )

Icons are available for all nominees on the final ballot. They can be picked up here. )

Thanks again and see you next year!! and we'll finish much much earlier, I promise *g*
[identity profile] foxrafer.livejournal.com
to cast your votes for the MOME Awards. Voting will close tomorrow at 11:59 pm eastern time. So check out the ballot and make those final selections.
[identity profile] foxrafer.livejournal.com
In a little over a week voting will close for this years [livejournal.com profile] mome_awards. There's been a great turnout over the past month, and there's still time to read through a few more categories and make your selections.

I think I've kept up with the e-mail ballot requests, but if you asked for a ballot and I didn't respond, please leave me a comment here and I'll get one out to you ASAP. Conversely, if you returned a ballot and I didn't send a response acknowledging I received it, please let me know as well.

On Wednesday, December 15, at 11:59 pm eastern time, the category polls will close so check out the ballot and if you have any questions, just let me know.
[identity profile] foxrafer.livejournal.com
At long last the 2010 MOME Award voting has begun. This year there are 73 different pairs over 71 categories. The general categories have the greatest mix and may include up to five different pairs in one group. You'll find a variety of stories (fluff, angst, romance, dark, etc.) so make note of headers when reading. Vote in as many categories as you can, and in each group please read every story before making your choice. You might discover a new favorite writer and be surprised by a previously unknown gem. Voting closes on Wednesday, December 15 at 11:59 pm EDT.

The ballot is comprised of a series of polls, one poll for each category. It's important to click the "submit poll" button underneath the text box when you enter a selection for each category to ensure your vote is registered. Poll results will not be viewable and once you've submitted a vote, the text box will disappear. You do not have to vote for each category at one time. To review or change your vote, click on the poll number, select "fill out poll" and your previous response will be displayed.

Only members of the awards community will be able to vote by filling in the polls. (If you are "watching" the comm, you may need to go back and join in order to vote.) If you do not wish to join the community, please send an e-mail to mome.awards@gmail.com to receive a ballot. E-mail ballots will only be accepted from those addresses where ballots were sent. Each year a good percentage of the votes come by e-mail so please don't hesitate to request a ballot if you prefer this method of voting.

Have fun and enjoy the stories!

2010 MOME Awards Ballot )
[identity profile] foxrafer.livejournal.com
Sorry for the delay. Everything should be coded and ready to go some time tomorrow afternoon (east coast time in the US).
[identity profile] foxrafer.livejournal.com
I believe we're on track for the ballot to be posted on Monday, November 1 *fingers crossed*. But I need some help reaching a few of the nominated authors. I just sent follow-up messages, but if you know any of the following people and have a way of getting in touch with them, could you please ask them to get in touch with me either here or at mome.awards AT gmail DOT com

Thanks for your help!

[livejournal.com profile] camesawconquerd
[livejournal.com profile] dr_mccoy1701
[livejournal.com profile] elmathelas
[livejournal.com profile] iamascavanger
[livejournal.com profile] jhobbit
[livejournal.com profile] lemonade_lady
[livejournal.com profile] melle
[livejournal.com profile] northatlantic
[livejournal.com profile] pikasafire
[livejournal.com profile] your_own_path

An update

Oct. 19th, 2010 05:39 am
[identity profile] foxrafer.livejournal.com
A combination of being overly ambitious and the wonderful "problem" of having more nominations than I estimated has resulted in me not contacting authors on Monday like I had hoped. I'd say I'll make it today but to be on the safe side I'm going to say e-mails will go out on Wednesday. Sorry for the delay and thanks for everyone sticking with me.
[identity profile] foxrafer.livejournal.com
So that's two years in a row I've had difficulty getting online at almost the exact same time of year and unfortunately both times has meant the awards schedule has fallen to pieces. I am very sorry that yet again the MOMEs has been on hold for so long. I promise you that nothing has been lost; I just wasn't able to access it and keep things rolling.

For those that are wondering: This is a solo project because for this kind of awards set up I firmly believe it's better that anyone "behind the scenes" should not be allowed to nominate, vote or have a story in the running, and I don't want anyone I know to be forced not to participate because they're helping me. (I really like the set up of the MEFAs, which I think eliminates those potential conflicts of interest through a really great process, but one I wouldn't be able to manage, unfortunately.) This is why it only takes one person to have a problem for the whole thing to fall behind. I do need to consider the timing of the awards for next year, as clearly this time of year is proving to be difficult for me and I don't want this radio silence and resulting delays to become a regular "feature."

With that said, I hope I haven't lost a lot of you and that you're willing to hang in there while I pull the proposed ballot together and contact the authors for their approval. At the latest (and if everything goes as planned) I hope to begin e-mailing everyone by the end of the weekend which could mean the ballot would be finalized and posted in anywhere from one to two weeks. (To help speed things along I may post a list of authors here and/or at my journal so others can help me get in touch with people from the beginning; I haven't decided if that would seem like overkill or put too much pressure on people to participate but we'll see.) That would mean things would be up for reading and voting by the end of the month, voting would take place through November ending around mid-December, and the results would be posted shortly thereafter. Not exactly the timetable we started with, and we're bumping into NanoWrimo participation time which is a little troublesome. If you think this timing really won't work, please let me know. I am *very* open to suggestions; perhaps it would be best to keep voting open until the end of the year to ensure everyone who will be busy writing in November and won't have time to read and vote can still participate.

I'll keep you updated as we go along. I believe we're good to go as far as contacting the authors in the next few days and hopefully we'll hear back from everyone quickly. Once again, I apologize for this huge delay; thank you for your understanding and patience.
[identity profile] foxrafer.livejournal.com
It's hard to believe that the end of the month is literally around the corner. Which means there are only a few days remaining to nominate those stories you think are worthy of recognition. But there's good news. Due to some technical problems I will have limited online access until after Labor Day. As a result, I've decided to extend the nomination period until the end of the day on Tuesday, September 7 (that's 11:59 p.m. eastern time). That's one more additional week to comb through your bookmarks, memories and favorites and find those exceptional stories!

I'm going to try and hit a few comms before I get kicked offline today but I'm not sure how many promotional posts I'll be able to make. If you have any time to post about the approaching awards deadline at your journals I'd really appreciate it.

Thanks to everyone for your participation! If you have any questions you may leave them here or send an e-mail to mome.awards@gmail.com. Someone I know will be checking both places for messages but there may be a slight delay in getting a response as everything will almost always be going through a third party.
[identity profile] foxrafer.livejournal.com
As the nomination period has just started, I wanted to address the issue of word counts. The categories are divided by pairing and length of fic, so part of the nomination requirement is including how many words are in a story.

I know this can be a tedious task. But while I'm sure many people are able to look at a web page or a series of chapters and make a pretty good guesstimate as to the number of words, believe me when I say that many people cannot. Every year I do random checks and every year I find multiple errors. One wrong count can mean several categories get rearranged. Instead of having both long and novel-length categories, we may now have only a long fiction category; instead of a pairing having its own short fiction category it may now have to be melded into a general category. And that's just the possible impact from one mistake. There's never only one wrong count so imagine at the end of the nomination period before I can contact authors to let them know they're on the ballot I have to categorize and recategorize because several counts are off.

I'm not saying this so people feel sorry for me; I love doing the awards because I feel it keeps the LotR fandom love alive and it puts a bunch of great fics in one place for people to enjoy throughout the year. But while I appreciate that getting a count for ten long stories is time consuming, imagine having to get counts for over a hundred. It's not a pretty sight. :-)

One thing I often suggest (if someone is finding it difficult) is that people contact the author and ask them for the count. On the plus side you may make their day to learn that someone feels their story is worthy of a nomination. Conversely if they'd rather not participate you know in advance and haven't taken any additional time getting a count. And to the writers out there, it would be great if you considered adding the word count to your posts and the total word count from a multi-chapter fic to the final chapter. These are just suggestions; clearly no one is required to contact an author or to add counts to their stories. But I wanted to bring it up in hopes that if even a handful of people do, it may make the nomination period a little easier.

If you have any questions or suggestions, please let me know. You can leave a comment here or send me an e-mail. Thanks for listening and have fun finding those great stories!

Edit: Firefox users may have a really easy option available through the Word Count Plus add-on. Thanks to [livejournal.com profile] vamp_ress for the tip!
[identity profile] foxrafer.livejournal.com


Nominations are now being accepted for the Men of Middle-earth Awards!

A pairing will only become its own category if it receives at least five distinct nominations in a specific fic size. If awards are going to be presented to as wide a variety of pairings as possible, it's important that we receive a lot of nominations.

Nomination Tip: If you know of at least three ficlets (or drabbles, short fiction, etc.) in your favorite pairing that you consider to be exceptional and worthy of recognition, consider nominating all three and not just the one you like the most. That way you can almost guarantee that pairing will have its own category in that particular fic size.

You don't have to be a member to submit a story. So spread the word, find those exemplary stories and nominate, nominate, nominate!

Details inside )

Profile

mome_awards: (Default)
Men of Middle-earth Awards

April 2017

S M T W T F S
      1
2345 678
9101112131415
16171819 202122
23242526272829
30      

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Sep. 25th, 2017 01:08 pm
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios